Every two months or so in Uganda I would go to the capital city Kampala in order to buy cheese, chicken breasts, milk and other western style foods to consume during the next couple months. Invariably, as we would arrive back to our rural homes a crowd of children would arrive and watch us unload boxes of food. Sometimes they would see the frozen meat. These moments would engender one of a couple feelings in me. Sometimes I would feel pity, or shame, or guilt about these hungry little eyes looking at me.
The problem that I had with all these emotions is that they mainly had to do with my conscience and had little to do with real empathy towards these poor children. I didn't understand what it was to want food, or clothing, or things in general.
So when I hunt my memories for some understanding of the poor, this is what I come up with, for better or for worse.
I'm 13 years old. It's the last week of school. All of our books are in, and the grades our finalized. The only reason we are in school is that the schoolboard said we needed to have x amount of days in this school year. I have almost made it through.
I'm 13 years old. It's the last week of school. All of our books are in, and the grades our finalized. The only reason we are in school is that the schoolboard said we needed to have x amount of days in this school year. I have almost made it through.
In that last hysterical week of parties and field days we go outside toI glance over my shoulder and see a couple, leaning against a tree, doing their best to resemble an uptruned arachnid. Except that the boy's hands were working the girls breasts like I'd seen a fat woman on television work dough. I stared and stared at them. Soon my friends noticed them too. We all stared.
Here was a moment where we saw with our own eyes something going on that we had not even imagined doing. Ever. Yes we often imagine the pubescent breast's of our classmates. We also imagined touching them. But we never once though in a million years to knead those very same breasts leaning against a tree at school one sunny afternoon while the other boys run after each other with super-soakers and water balloons.
And this radical widening of our frame of reference was immediately crushing. For even as the unknown is revealed it seems no less possible for us in our hopeless geekiness. Never in my wildest dreams could I imagine being that guy-against-the-tree. It was beyong my means but I wanted it desparately. So much so that I imagined kicking that guy in the face, supplanting him, and kneeding that dough.
This is as close as I can get, I think to empathy. I don't think poor people live in a constant state of envy, and my story is far less serious than theirs. But I do think that when the poor are confronted with their need through seeing the wealth of others, my emotions from above and their emotions are the same.
Matt,
The only thing I wonder is if this assumes that if I am poor I long for things I don't have? Is that always true? I would guess it is most often. I don't know. What do you think?
I don't think the poor live in a constant state of longing for what they don't have. But being poor means having not enough of what you need. So I do think that when shown what you need you are going to long for it.
Posted by: matt at January 9, 2007 10:17 AMI agree with your assessment that much of what we feel with respect to the poor has much more to do with guilt than compassion. The more time I spend around those who make poverty a major talking point, the harder I find it to take them seriously, as the contrast between their politics and lifestyle tends to erode any moral high ground that a "preferential option for the poor" would tend to confer. Most of the people I know that talk a lot about the poor, especially those I know at Notre Dame, probably wouldn't be caught dead actually spending time with them. This is amplified by the fact that most of the action plans described actually do quite little to alleviate the suffering of those in need and usually wind up simply being really cool cap-feathers for socially-minded post-collegians who find regular employment aesthetically distasteful.
Yet at the same time, I wonder what to do about this. There needs to be a way of caring for the poor that doesn't involve massive guilt trips as motivation for action or funding. Compassion and guilt seem to me to be antithetical. I think until we recognize that just as having money does not confer any special moral status, not having money doesn't either, we will be unable to deal with the poor as poor people instead of simply instantiations of social problems. There's nothing noble about poverty, and treating it like there is prevents us from connecting with the people we should be caring for.
Posted by: ryan at January 9, 2007 10:49 AMThis may seem a bit trite, but I think that there is truth in Jesus's statements about the blessedness of the poor. The implication I get out of this is that God is with the poor. Community with the poor is a special source of community with God. This can lead to falsely ennobling the poor, but one the other hand, I don't think poverty can be erradicated by our hands.
Posted by: matt at January 10, 2007 8:18 AM